Forums » Go
Incorrectly marked stones as seki
Replies: 1   Pages: 1   Most recent reply posted by: TCA NightWalker (Jan 2, 2022 9:38 PM)
Welcome, Guest
Login
Guest Settings
 Reply to this Topic  Post New Topic  Search Forum
Previous Topic
  Back to Topic List
Next Topic
Replies: 1   Pages: 1  
BobTheJoe

Posts: 1
Registered: Apr, 2012

Incorrectly marked stones as seki Posted: Dec 25, 2021 11:52 PM
Reply
In the game I played against cdlee today at 5:43pm, the system incorrectly marked 6-7 stones in the corner and along the side as seki, and the 8 points of territory they surrounded as dame. It was on a 15x15 board but w's stones were exactly like this (the "seki" was the upper right stones): http://ps.waltheri.net/719929

It's not clear why this happened, because the position doesn't involve anything close to a seki.

Why did it make a mistake like this? And is there a way to correct the system? If not, there really should be.


TCA NightWalker

Posts: 260
Registered: Nov, 2006

Re: Incorrectly marked stones as seki Posted: Jan 2, 2022 9:38 PM
Reply
Ok, I was hoping someone else would comment on this, but here's my guess:
First, I will assume that top right corner is T19. Then, black can pretty much force this sequence if it's their move:
(Black) T12 T11 T14 T15 S17 S16 T17
After which white cannot answer T16 due to T14 eating white group, and cannot play T18 due to T19, thus two black stones on S17 and T17 live, and white side dies after black add T18 and T19 (bottom half has just 1 eye).
So, I guess evaluation software sees this killing sequence for black if it's blacks move, and thus knows white needs one more stone to truly live there. Hence thinks that territory is 'undecided' yet.
Let me know your thoughts.
Artik

Replies: 1   Pages: 1  
Previous Topic
  Back to Topic List      Top of the page
Next Topic